Hardshell vs. Softshell Rooftop Tents: Which Is Right for You?

Hardshell vs. Softshell Rooftop Tents: Which Is Right for You?

You've decided you want a rooftop tent — now comes the big question: hardshell or softshell? Here's everything you need to know to make the right call.

What's the Difference?

At their core, both tent types mount to your roof rack and give you an elevated sleeping platform off the ground. The difference is in how they're built and how they open.

  • Softshell tents fold out like a book or unfold accordion-style, with a fabric shell supported by poles — similar to a traditional tent but on your roof.
  • Hardshell tents have a rigid shell (aluminum or fiberglass) that either folds in half (clamshell) or telescopes upward (wedge). They pop open in seconds with no assembly required.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Hardshell Softshell
Setup time 30–60 seconds 3–5 minutes
Pack height Low profile Taller when packed
Weight 130–200 lbs 65–130 lbs
Aerodynamics Excellent More wind drag
Insulation Better (rigid walls) Good with quality canvas
Durability Excellent Very good
Interior space Slightly less headroom Often more headroom
Price $1,500–$4,000+ $800–$2,000
Best for Frequent campers, overlanders Weekend warriors, first-timers

When to Choose a Hardshell

  • You camp frequently and want the fastest setup possible
  • You want a low-profile look on your vehicle day-to-day
  • You drive at highway speeds regularly and want less wind noise/drag
  • You camp in variable weather and want maximum protection
  • Budget is less of a concern and you want a premium, long-term investment

When to Choose a Softshell

  • You're new to rooftop camping and want an affordable entry point
  • Your vehicle has a lower roof load rating (softshells are significantly lighter)
  • You want more interior headroom and a spacious feel
  • You camp occasionally and setup time isn't a priority
  • You want to maximize your budget for other gear

What About Canvas Softshells?

High-quality softshell tents use canvas or polycotton fabric which breathes better than synthetic materials, handles condensation well, and provides excellent insulation in cold weather. If you go softshell, look for polycotton over basic polyester.

The Verdict

There's no wrong answer — it comes down to how often you camp and what you value most.

Choose hardshell if: speed and convenience matter most, and you're a committed overlander.

Choose softshell if: you're getting started, budget-conscious, or want maximum interior space.

Shop Rooftop Tents →

Still not sure? Reach out and we'll help you find the right fit for your vehicle and camping style.

Back to blog